skip to main content

October 8, 2019

There is no doubt that social media has its benefits, especially for medical practices that have come to use it for marketing and advertising.  However, risks are lurking.  On October 2, 2019, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights (“OCR”) entered into a $10,000 settlement with a dental practice (the “Practice”) for disclosing protected health information of a patient when responding to a review on a Yelp page. 

In this matter, a patient complained to OCR that the Practice impermissibly disclosed the patient’s name and details about his/her condition on Yelp.  Upon its investigation, OCR found that the Practice: (1) impermissibly disclosed the protected health information (“PHI”) of multiple patients in response to patient reviews; (2) did not have any policies or procedures regarding disclosures of PHI to ensure that any social media interactions protected the PHI of its patients; and (3) had a noncompliant Notice of Privacy Practices. In addition to the settlement amount, the Practice also entered into a Resolution Agreement with OCR whereby the Practice has to, among other requirements, develop and maintain policies and procedures, revise its Notice of Privacy Practices, and apply and document sanctions for workforce members who fail to comply with such policies and procedures. 

Interestingly, OCR noted that it drastically reduced the settlement amount due to the Practice’s size.  However, it is clear from the settlement and corresponding press release that providers of all types and sizes should be on high alert for this type of violation. Specifically, OCR’s director, Roger Severino, stated the following: “Social media is not the place for providers to discuss a patient’s care . . . [d]octors and dentists must think carefully about patient privacy before responding to online reviews.”

As a result of this enforcement action, covered entities of all sizes should re-examine their policies and procedures to ensure they are clear that providers are not to disclose any PHI on a social media website, even if prompted by a patient complaint. This advice extends not only to Yelp, but also to any social media page linked with the covered entity (e.g. Instagram, Facebook, Twitter etc.).  

If you have any questions or need assistance with policy and procedure drafting or review, please contact: Stephanie S. Sobkowiak at 203.772.7782 or or Daniel J. Kagan, at 203.772.7726 or

PDF File hc_ocr_fines_dental_practice_10000_for_social_media_disclosures_october_2019_copy1.pdf

Related Information